Before you ask which app or which service, ask what type of firm you are actually trying to build

accounting firm strategy

Share This Post

Every year, right around the third week of November, the same itch shows up in accounting firms. What app should I use? What workflow should I switch to? What services should I add? It feels like the moment to find a blueprint, a clean set of answers to implement before tax season. 

The honest response answers  a different question entirely, and it tends to catch people off guard: what do you actually want to do? Not what is possible, not what a consultant would recommend, but what kind of firm are you trying to build, who do you want to serve, and what do you want it to look like in six months and in twelve.

Almost nobody can answer that straight away. Ask a firm owner to name five changes they want to make, and most cannot get to five. They have been so busy churning out returns and closing books that the realquestion has gone unanswered. And here is the thing: until it is answered, no app, no hire, and no new service can be chosen well, because there is nothing to choose them against.

Why is “which tool?” the wrong first question?

It is the wrong first question because tools, services, and hires are all answers to a prior question that has not been asked. Which app is best depends entirely on what you are trying to do with it. Which service to add depends on what work you actually want to be doing. Which person to hire depends on where the firm is going. Skip the direction and every one of those decisions becomes a guess.

There is a reason this feels backwards to do. Naming your direction is slow, quiet work, and churning out the next return feels productive. So the groundwork gets glossed over, and the firm grows anyway, quite quickly in fact. But a firm built without that direction has a habit of sucking the life out of the person who built it, because it grew into whatever walked through the door rather than into anything they chose. This is the real work behind re-engineering your firm around the work you actually want: deciding, on purpose, what the firm is for before deciding what it runs on.

The pull of the shiny thing

Once you have no clear direction, everything shiny becomes a distraction that looks like progress. A new service offering. A new app with an impressive demo. A new client who came through a referral, who you get along with, who seems like a good fit, except they do not actually match the business you are trying to build. You take them on anyway, because saying yes feels like momentum.

It is not momentum. It is drift. Each shiny yes pulls the firm a little further from the thing you said you wanted, and a year later you are busy, tired, and no closer to the firm of the future you had in mind. Direction is what lets you say a calm no to the attractive distraction, and a calm yes to the thing that actually moves you forward. Without it, you are at the mercy of whatever is newest and loudest.

What do you do with the work you do not want?

Here is a liberating idea for anyone who has decided what they want their firm to be. The work you do not enjoy does not have to be work you personally keep doing, and it does not have to be work the firm refuses either.

If a disliked but necessary task is critical to your goal, the move is not to grit your teeth through it forever. It is to funnel it. Segment it to a team or a person who actually likes that kind of work, or hand it to an outside team entirely. This is not a fantasy. Firms do it constantly, carving out the work nobody on the core team wants and giving it to people who light up when it lands on their desk. And people genuinely do light up, because what one person dreads, another finds satisfying. Matching the work to the people who enjoy it makes everyone’s day better and frees your best people for the higher-level work only they can do. That freed-up space is the whole point. It is hard to think about the firm you want to build when every hour is spoken for by work you resent. Creating space, by funnelling the dreaded work to someone who wants it, is often the first practical step toward building anything different. It is also exactly what good CAS support that gives you space to build the firm you want is for.

Choosing your clients on purpose

The same discipline applies to who you work with, and it is where a lot of firms quietly lose control of their own direction. Many practices will claim expertise in whatever industry walks through the door. A nonprofit calls, and suddenly the firm is an expert in nonprofits, on the strength of one audit five years ago. It feels like good business. It is usually how a firm ends up serving everyone and fitting no one.

The firms that stay healthy are comfortable saying no to a client type that does not fit, even a profitable one. There is real discipline in deciding, for example, that you do not want to take on a particular industry, however much work it might bring. This matters most when a new client type would quietly change everything underneath you. Moving into e-commerce, for instance, is not just a new logo on the client list. It can mean hundreds of transactions a day instead of a tidy monthly bill, a different app stack, a different skill set your team does not yet have, and clients who need to talk to you constantly rather than twice a year. Wandering into that without deciding to is how a firm built for one kind of work ends up drowning in another.

And the timing cuts deep here. Asking your team to spin up an entirely new skill set in the weeks before tax season, for a client type you drifted into rather than chose, is a reliable way to push good people toward the door, in an industry where finding and keeping them is already the hardest problem there is.

Start with the question, not the tool

So when the itch to change arrives this month, and it arrives for almost everyone around now, resist the urge to jump straight to picking apps and tools. Start one step back. What do you want to do? What do you want to stop doing? Who do you actually want to serve? Then, and only then, do the questions about tools, teams, and services have good answers, because they finally have something to serve. 

If freeing up space to even think about those questions would help, that is a conversation our outsourced back office accounting support team has with firms all the time, and now, just before the season, is exactly when it is worth having.

For more on building a better accounting practice, MoneyPenny hosts Beyond Numbers, a podcast of practical conversations on capacity, workflow, pricing, technology and the realities of running a firm. Watch on YouTube, or listen on Apple or Spotify.

More To Explore